DHS Officials Contradict Agency Stance on Filming Agents
During a Senate oversight hearing on Thursday, top immigration officials broke with their department’s long-standing narrative by admitting under oath that filming federal agents is not a crime. The testimony directly challenges claims by DHS leadership that recording officers during operations constitutes a felony offense.
Senator Rand Paul (R-Ky.) pressed the heads of ICE and CBP regarding the legal status of bystanders recording law enforcement. When asked if filming agents amounted to an assault or any criminal act, acting ICE head Todd Lyons and CBP Commissioner Rodney Scott both answered with a flat "no." This acknowledgment exposes a sharp divide within the Department of Homeland Security, which has spent months asserting the opposite.
Secretary Kristi Noem and agency spokespeople have previously characterized the act of videotaping officers as "doxing" and a potential federal felony. This rhetoric has manifested on the ground, where agents in states like Minnesota and Maine have threatened or detained civilians for recording. While courts have consistently upheld the First Amendment right to film police, the DHS maintained a June bulletin labeling such actions as "unlawful civil unrest." The admission by agency leaders now complicates the department's aggressive stance as it faces ongoing legal challenges regarding its treatment of journalists and the public.
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first!